As you might guess, I’m in favor of the First
Amendment to the Constitution. Without it, we could not speak our minds
without fear of persecution. Artists and photographers could not freely
explore subjects and display their work. Writers could not opine and
publish without fear of censorship. The People could not criticize the
Government and not be incarcerated. Free speech is a cornerstone of our
society. It’s necessary and it must be protected. However, we also may
be exposed to opinions that make us feel uncomfortable. We may even be
repulsed by something we read, hear or see. So it goes in a society that
protects with law its peoples’ ability to speak and share information.
Well, physicians are people too. It’s a pithy
statement, but it bears saying, as the censor mongers have turned their
attention to physicians blogs. I mean really. Should a society that
permits the sale of musical lyrics that promote unthinkable acts, also
censor the free exchange of information between doctors in forums
specifically designed for that purpose? If I turn on The View, aren’t
I ultimately responsible for the opinions to which I may be exposed?
For the first time since the invention of the golf
course, physicians have a location where they can share their personal
thoughts, feelings and experiences with like-minded professionals.
What’s wrong with that? Plenty, if you fear doctors will reveal your
private information on the Internet, where it’s fodder for the world’s
gristmill. Should we regulate that activity in the name of security? The
physician’s code of ethics already disallows the revealing of private
information that may identify and potentially harm patients. HIPAA adds
legislation. We trust physicians with our health. Can we not also trust
them with our privacy? I think we can. Besides, if my trust is misplaced
and I can prove that I’ve been damaged, I can seek recompense in the
courts. Do I need more protection than that? I don’t think so.
The benefits of physicians blogs is widespread and
growing. Hundreds exist all over the world on all medical specialties
from oncology to neonatology to emergency first responders. Some deal
with specific topics, such as patient care, while others simply provide
a forum for open discussions among healthcare providers. Some enable
potential patients to openly communicate with physicians, get advice
from specialists, or simply lurk and learn from reading the posts.
Others require participants to prove they are healthcare providers and
register before entering. Return visitors must log in with a unique
identifier each time they re-enter the site. In fact, there are blogs on
most disciplines related to healthcare, such as marketing and diagnosis.
In general, the information shared on these blogs is more sensitive and
therefore protected by the login process. The same process and
procedures govern and protect our private financial information on bank
Web sites. Why is it not good enough for physicians blogs?
Clearly, doctors exchanging information with other
doctors to gain knowledge and awareness is a boon to healthcare that
decreases the potential for error, while increasing patient safety. Is
there potential for abuse? Of course there is. However, the free
exchange of information over the Internet has revolutionized industries
all over the world. Healthcare is no different. It profoundly affects
each of our lives, and yet, technologically, in many ways, it has lagged
behind, due partly to sloth and partly
to fear.
Let’s not let fear keep it there.